Wait…a few episodes Emma made a huge stink about ‘knowing’ when people are lying and telling the truth when the Regina/Archie case was in question…
And now something that can ruin EVERYONE’S LIVES comes into town and she can’t tell that he was lying to her? Did she even try to focus on it? She didn’t even tell anyone ” I know he’s telling the truth “, she just…took his word for it and left.
Some ‘superpower’ ye got there.
( Personally I think it’s one of the stupidest ‘character traits’ about her…if you can even call it that. )